FOR GOVERNMENT AGENCIES AND LEGISLATIVE STAFF

The measurement the policy conversation has been waiting for.

We read public job posting endpoints on a daily schedule and record what they do. Dated. Verifiable. Independent. Built for citation.

Every figure in the current ghost jobs debate comes from a company with something to sell. The estimates run from 14 percent to 47 percent because no two use the same definition. The Congressional Research Service told Congress in April 2025 there are no official statistics.

We are not a vendor with a product opinion. We are an observational registry. We watch what job postings do. We record it with dates, at the posting level, in a way that is independently reproducible. We publish the methodology before we publish any number. We publish our corrections when we are wrong.

That is the standard this conversation has been missing.

JURISDICTIONBILLSTATUS
New YorkS8877 / A6292APassed both houses Jun 2, 2026. Awaiting delivery to the Governor.
PennsylvaniaHB 2321Referred to House Labor & Industry, Mar 26, 2026. No action since.
New JerseyS2136Cleared the Senate Labor Committee May 11, 2026. Referred to Senate Budget and Appropriations.
CaliforniaAB 1251Passed the Assembly 62-9. Held under submission in Senate Appropriations, Aug 29, 2025. No action since.
Ontario, CanadaEmployment Standards ActIn effect Jan 1, 2026. Postings must state whether they are for an existing vacancy. Applies to employers with 25 or more employees.
Status as of Oct 24, 2026. Sources on the methodology page.

The bills that are moving right now.

Five jurisdictions have active or enacted legislation targeting ghost job postings. Here is the current status of each, with sources on the methodology page.

LEGISLATIVE DOSSIER SUMMARY

Full evidentiary records, statutory texts, and committee hearing transcripts are cataloged in our primary legislative registry.

What is in the record.

We check public ATS endpoints and employer careers sites daily across major platforms. For each posting we observe, we record the date it first appeared, every subsequent confirmation it was still live, any change to its title, salary range, or description, and the date it was last seen before going dark.

We do not infer employer intent. We do not estimate. We record what is observable and say plainly what is not.

What this record supportsSCOPED CAPABILITIES
  • •Longitudinal posting lifecycle data by employer, sector, and geography, at the posting level.
  • •Comparison of observed posting duration against published workforce actions: WARN notices, SEC filings, bankruptcy proceedings.
  • •Time-series analysis of posting and reposting patterns before and after major labor market events.
  • •Employer-level records with dates and sources, and a dated methodology exhibit.
What this record does not supportEXPLICIT LIMITATIONS
  • •National prevalence estimates. Our archive started in August 2026 and covers a subset of the employer population. We do not publish numbers we cannot defend.
  • •Claims about employer intent. We observe behavior. Conclusions about intent are for counsel and courts.
  • •Coverage of platforms where observation is prohibited. Individual URL checks are available on request and are legally distinct from bulk observation.

How we work with government agencies.

FRAMEWORK 01AGENCY PILOT

Pilot Engagement

A structured pilot covering a defined employer set, sector, or geography over a defined period. Deliverables include a methodology exhibit, the raw observation data, and a written summary.

FRAMEWORK 02REGULATORY / INVESTIGATIVE

Enforcement Evidence

Posting-level longitudinal records for a specific employer, covering the period under investigation, with a methodology exhibit suitable for a legal proceeding. We testify to our methodology. We do not testify to employer intent.

FRAMEWORK 03SCHOLARLY / ACADEMIC

Research Access

Academic and policy researchers can request access to aggregate data under a data use agreement. Write to govt@hiringrecord.com to request access.

FRAMEWORK 04COMMITTEE HEARING

Legislative Testimony

We are available to present methodology and findings to legislative committees. We present observations. What the data means for policy is your determination.

The record is open. Built for citation.

Our numbered report series at /reports publishes findings with permanent URLs and machine-readable data alongside every document. Each report names what it cannot answer as clearly as what it can. A CRS staffer or a legislative counsel can cite a specific report, a specific URL, and a specific version of the methodology, and know it will still resolve in two years.

Our methodology is versioned. Prior versions stay live at their own URLs. Our corrections log publishes every error we have found and corrected, with the cause, the fix, and the date.

These are primary sources. Use them as such.

Talk to us before you draft the RFP.

Government procurement is built around incumbents. If you write the requirements after talking to us, they'll fit what we can actually do. If you write them before, they may not.

Tell us what you're trying to measure, what you're trying to prove, or what you've been asked to produce. We'll tell you honestly what the record currently supports and what it doesn't.

govt@hiringrecord.com · Subject: Government inquiry · [Agency] · [State]

The Hiring Record is an independent observational registry. We do not accept payment from employers for favorable treatment. We do not remove accurate observations. We publish all corrections openly.

Conflict rules stated in full at hiringrecord.com/methodology#conflict-rules

For Government · The Hiring Record